Entradas

Mostrando las entradas de octubre 3, 2014

What makes logical necessities true?

For example: A.Jonah Hill is alive or he is not. What makes A true? As far I can tell, there are four kinds of proposals: 1.Contingentism: A is true because Jonah Hill is alive (or because of whatever makes Jonah be alive).2.Essentialism: A is true in virtue of disjunction and negation having the logical nature they have.3.Representationalism: A is true because the actual world is a possible world. Pros and Cons: 4.Contingentism: A is true because Jonah Hill is alive (or because of whatever makes Jonah be alive).a.PROS: i.Does not require postulating special entities like worlds and logical operations.ii.Offers a uniform account of the way operations affect truthmaking for contingent and necessary truths, i.e., it respects the following truth-making principle: truth-bearers of the form PvQ are made true by what makes P true (if P is true) plus what makes Q true (if it is true).b.CONS: i.Makes necessary truths less metaphysically fundamental than contingent facts.ii.Truth-making without …